Ingrid Betancourt was liberated from the FARC guerillas who were holding her yesterday. I was certainly happy to hear this news. A strong blow to the FARC is likely good for
From the CBC article: Betancourt exclaimed, "God, this is a miracle." and those words were echoed by Amanda Howes, the niece of one of the freed
Really? This was a miracle? I would say it had much more to do with the intelligence gathering of the Colombian security services, and with the professional training and actions of the soldiers involved in the planning and execution of the operation. There was no divine intervention in order to pull it off, and calling it a miracle diminishes the hard work of real people that went into a successful operation. Amanda Howes is certainly right that if we call this a miracle, it really does redefine the term.
This terminology comes up again and again when accidents are less severe than we think they should be. Planes crash in a rich country airport, no one dies, and a few people escape with broken bones and bruises. “Oh it’s a miracle” people exclaim. No. It’s not. Decades of engineering innovation, assessment of past accidents, training of pilots and ground crew, as well as emergency responders are what is responsible for the lack of catastrophe.
Next time you hear someone say that something is miraculous, take a second to think about it. Could there be a different explanation than divine intervention? Look for a person or process to thank, and thank them instead. Just think of what your job satisfaction would be like if every time you accomplished something, an invisible, untouchable, uncontactable creator being got the credit.
1 comment:
Though I agree its not a miracle in the strict sense that it was not a God-willed contravention of the natural law; however, I disagree with the claim that "calling it a miracle diminishes the hard work of real people that went into a successful operation." Is this necessarily true? I do not think so. Why does simply referring to the situation as a miracle deminish the others' hard work? People can simultaneously work hard for something but have divine assistance. God's hand does not diminish human action it redirects and perfects it. As far as I know there were other contingencies - other than hard work i.e. human agency - which made this outcome possible. For example an increasingly receptive host government. Did "chance" not at all play a role in this situation? While it probably would have been better to say "God brought me back home," I still don't understand the intense anomosity over calling it a miracle. At most, it warrants our calm correction for the misuse of the term.
Post a Comment